If you’re looking for a short answer, then no, you can’t completely disable the App Library. App Library can only be accessed by swiping past the last home screen page on your iPhone. Here’s how to do it: App Library gives you the option to automatically move newly downloaded apps to the library instead of just adding them to the home screen. Note that the icons in the App Library all have X buttons instead of minus signs to indicate that tapping one will delete the app. How to delete an iPhone app on iOS 14 devices The deletion process changes for anyone with a more up-to-date device running iOS 14 . Why even change things just for the sake of change? I didn’t like the new widget layout either, but finally got back to something like the way I had it before the iOS update. In the app library, these are all lumped together with my banking and credit card apps and Contacts (which I use almost exclusively for phone numbers) and Calendar, which makes no sense at all. I am giving you a chance to fix this crap App Library and remove it completely from my phone Or u will lose me to SAMSUNG smart phone forever☹️☹️ probably along with a lot of other usually loyal i Phone users The categories are all wrong for me, and they can’t even be edited!?! My home was not cluttered to begging with. Frankly, “Productivity” isn’t even something I value! THE NEW APP LIBRARY Is SH**. I don’t have that many I leave in my inbox but there are 2 or 3 that I need to follow up on with something and I want to delete or put in a folder when I want to. As many others have stated, I created all the folders I ever needed and named them so that I could always find what I wanted easily. One of those features is the App Library, which stores your Apps in category folders. To remove an app, press and hold on the app you want to delete until a pop-up shows. I use Mail almost exclusively for social interactions, and Zoom for school lectures, and WordPress to edit my artist website. Give the option of turning it OFF, #Apple! Go to the App Library and tap the search field to open the list. It’s because this model of the iPhone working device presented the brand new App Library. At the top, you’ll see Remove App. Keep your Home screen clean but all your apps available with these easy steps. The arrangement is useless! I was completely shocked, but…, How to customize the Photos widget in iOS 14, Switch from Grid view to List view in iOS 14, How to Stop Your Mac From Updating to macOS Big Sur, What Is Rosetta 2? To find anything you have to open various folders until you hit the right one. Make sure new apps don’t save to the App Library, 2. Make sure all your Home screens are visible. An update to turn it off would be quite easy. MY phone should be editable to MY likes and categories. And shoot them!!! Please remove App Library I don’t want it , it is just annoying and if this is not going to be removed will go to Android, Please remove App Library I don’t want it or am going to Android. Next, tap the “Remove App” option from the context menu. It makes more sense for the App Library to be a widget, up front for those who use it, than behind the home pages. This is supposed to “clean up “ the desk top but doubles my icons instead. Many people don’t want these new functions and should be optional. I don’t need apple’s recommendations on how they need organized. How to Delete Apps from iPhone & iPad via App Store with a Gesture Trick, How to Block & Unblock Email Addresses on Mail for Mac, How to Automatically Delete Emails from Blocked Senders on iPhone & iPad Mail, Beta 1 of MacOS Big Sur 11.2, iOS 14.4, iPadOS 14.4 Released for Testing, iOS 14.3 & iPadOS 14.3 Update Downloads Available Now, macOS Big Sur 11.1 Update Released to Download, Release Candidate for MacOS Big Sur 11.1 Released for Testing, iOS 14.3 Release Candidate Available for Beta Testers, How to Fix iPhone / iPad Keyboard Missing or Disappearing, How to Start & Stop Sharing Apple Music with Family Members, Can’t Access the 3-Month Fitness+ Trial? How to Access App Library in iOS 14. Please remove from my phone ASAP. And the great news is that it's available right now, to everyone with a compatible iPhone. Unhide All Home Screen Pages. I also have Aspergers and I don’t handle change very well. Touch and hold the app icon, then tap Delete App . Here are 4 steps to fix it. The app will now disappear from your home screen. How to Troubleshoot & Fix AirPods, iCloud Backup Failed on iPhone or iPad? Those are pretty much the options available at the moment. The favourites contacts was so important to me as I have serious health issues and if I neede to get hold of anyone for help I could swipe to the first home page see picture of the people I needed to contact and just tap their picture it was fantastic! Here's how to use the App Library to better organize your iPhone. Just make a Fkn phone. Like almost everyone here I abhor this feature. Lame lame lame. However, some people may have trouble getting used to it, and some would rather have all their apps on the home screen itself instead. App Library is one of the best new features and biggest visual changes that iOS 14 has to offer for iPhone. The introduction of iOS 14 added many new and exciting features to Apple’s operating system. Use the App Library to Find your Apps The real alternative is to go back to any Android. Tap ‘Remove app’ on the menu. You can even set … With App Library, Apple intends to clean up your home screen that’s cluttered with apps that you’ve installed over the years. Long-pressing any app icon will let you move it to only the App Library by tapping Remove App then Move to App Library. Please spend your time and money on something more useful. Solved: MacBook connects to Wi-Fi but has no Internet connection. How do we complain to apple about this stupid App Library. This reminds me of Microsoft’s first introduction of the ribbon in their office suite… they have clearly based the design of this on the masses of ignorant users that don’t turn off the ‘automatically send Apple your private details on your usage habits’ – in exactly the same way that Microsoft did, they have released a product that is beyond useless; it irritates me every time i accidentally scroll right too far and see it. I organise my apps the way I want to, thank you very much, not the way some fascist dictatorship wants me to. The new iPhone App Library is part of the iOS 14 update that also includes widgets, improved Maps, and much more. Hopefully, in the future, Apple will add an option to disable this feature and revert to the old ways. Then tap and hold the app’s icon in the search result. I already have a folder on my otherwise empty last page, called ‘Apple Shit’ where I store all the stuff they otherwise refuse to allow me to delete. App Library, the new widgets, the Translate app and improved Messages and Maps are all part of iOS 14. I had ALL my apps nicely arranged only on one Home Screen and I definitely did NOT need apple to do it for me. Apparently, Apple feels it necessary to aid its Kindergarten-level users, of which there may be more than anyone would have suspected. Check Out How iOS 14… The ribbon is still irritating, grouping features in a way that doesn’t match my work flow, it is a shame that Apple is now moving in the same direction; interfering with my workflow rather than improving it…. My hack to never look at this abomination of a “feature”: move a single useless app to it’s own page on the homescreen, so when I swipe right and I see an empty screen with only one app, I know to swipe back left. I don’t need someone micromanaging my apps. App Library Blows – quit changing stuff just to change stuff you f******g m***ns. Can’t you go back to that. -according to…? Begin by tapping and holding anywhere on the screen. App Library does not organize apps the way I want nor in categories I want. Great moments in product management; New Coke, removing the windows start button, iOS App Library. Tap “Remove App.”. Yes, we understand that this may seem a little silly, but take a look at the next two options as well. I will use huawei or samsung, Stupid and annoying app!!!! RELATED: How to Remove Apps and Pages from Your iPhone's Home Screen. So, if you’re interested in checking this out, you can learn how to add widgets to your iPhone home screen, which is easily one of the most popular new features available in the latest iOS releases. Should Apple give users the option to disable this feature on their iPhones? Thank you. Touch and hold an empty spot in the App Library to enter jiggle mode. You can review our privacy policy for additional information. Default apps, App Clips and the App Library are just a few of the great additions. When prompted, choose “Delete” to confirm. The setting to change that is now gone with this latest update. Mind you, if he hides his home screens and switches to the Library mode he will never see most of them again :), I already had my apps organized they way I wanted them. Recently installed apps. Please realize that most of your users have chosen to use iOS because it was more user (and family) friendly than Android. May be time to go back to android. By continuing to browse the site, closing this banner, scrolling this webpage, or clicking a link, you agree to these cookies. Tap on the search bar and type in the app name. Once you install a new app on your iPhone, the apps are automatically added to the App Library and categorized automatically. Still, it does keep your home screen cleaned up quite nicely. The App Library is an all-new way in iOS 14 to store your apps without needing them to appear on the Home Screen. I believe if Jobs were alive he would nix an idea like this or at least allow a patron to enable or disable this feature. Please remove App Library or am changing hand sets. How about offering the new behavior to the user, and if it sounds compelling, let them opt in? Your phone will now do what apple wants it to do, not what you want it to do. Shop on Amazon.com and help support OSXDaily! You want to change something in an upgrade? How to change your home screen on iOS 14. We hope you were able to use these alternative solutions to stop using App Library on your iPhone. Why do they always say we’re stupid for not liking changes we can’t use that are forced on us? The App Library can be accessed from your phone's home screen. I really don’t understand how this feature could make it to the end users, especially without an option to turn it off. We already could group apps together by dragging them together into a folder. Selecting Delete App will completely remove the app along with any data associated with it. As you know iOS 14 has many new features. This is because this version of the iPhone operating system introduced the new App Library . Not a big fan of using App Library on iPhone with iOS 14? I have my apps organised into folders of my making. Simply follow the steps below: Don’t forget you can also move and delete apps from App Library too if you want to. I haven’t seen the app library since the update. What’s Apple’s definition of recent? Get To Know Your New Mac. To see all the apps in a category, tap on the small app icons. Scroll down and tap on “Home Screen” to continue. Where is the App Library in iOS 14? Long-press on the home screen to enter jiggle mode and tap on the dot icon as shown below. Why would I want to add more steps to do the same task? I don’t use the App Library feature, as I’ve organized my apps into folders long ago, and I don’t like the repeats and weird auto-organization of App Library. And, with widgets in the new iOS 14, you can place those on your home screen instead. You can access your App Library by swiping left from your home screen. Quit treating people like babies! Swipe over to the right-most home screen to view your App Library. Ditto ditto. Here’s How to Fix & Troubleshoot. The possible exception for this is my Father in Law who has more apps than you could ever use in a life. As humans we use apps so differently that curating them for us is ludicrous. OK, so how long do they stay there? And I do Dare to say it I will switch to!!!! The App Library is a feature new with iOS 14 that automatically groups your apps by categories such as Suggestions, Recently Added, and themes like Games, Lifestyle, and Productivity. Fix Message App Problems, How to use Reminders on Mac, a complete user guide, How to transfer your photos from iCloud Photos to…, I love using voice memos, but in the case of longer memos–15 minutes or more–I often can’t replay them entirely.…, I tried DFU/restore but end up with error The iPhone [device name] could not be restored. Except for the alphabetized list, the App Library screen is pointless and dumb to me. iPad vs MacBook: Should You Buy the iPad Pro or the New MacBook Air? Let me have if I want to, but don’t shove it down my throat if I don’t ask it for!!!!! I want my iPhone’s screens as they used to be. Simply unhide these pages and you can easily restore how your home screen always used to look. I know very well how to arrange my apps in appropriate ways without Apple’s intervention. Another visual, yet functional addition to iOS 14 is home screen widgets. Go to the Home screen page with app that you want to remove. Like everybody else I’m seeing respond here, I hate the app library! Apparently the dweebs at Apple have come up with all they can think of to make their products desirable! Don’t make us able to scroll to the right more than we have home screens and show all the apps on the home screen again. I hate it. App library…another example of some lazy idiot 20 yr old developer who wants to take as many shortcuts in life as they can. It’s also worth pointing out that some people may have developed the muscle memory to quickly launch their favorite apps from a certain location on the home screen and this will mostly always be faster than using App Library to launch apps. And it worked. No regard to any of us who have used an iphone efficiently for a decade and have it set up like we want. If you’ve tried to get a hang of App Library after updating your iPhone to iOS 14, you may have hidden some of the pages of apps to tidy up your home screen. Get this crap off my phone. Did whomever came up with this idea come from Google? App Library in iOS 14 is a welcome addition and here to make your life easier through and through. We want that back. Maybe it’s not real security, but that’s how I want it, not a page someone can go to an access ALL my apps. Long press a blank part of your Home screen until the apps start to wiggle. It will be interesting to see how the tool develops over time. Why is my iPhone 11 or XS/XS Max/XR Display so dark and dim? iPhone stuck in Recovery mode? 1. As you can see, currently you can’t just turn off App Library, but you can avoid using App Library altogether as long as you don’t swipe past the last home screen page. App Library can only be accessed by swiping past the last home screen page on your iPhone. Reading all these comments, hearing from all my colleagues at work and also my family there’s one thing they all have in common. Apple in iOS 14 redesigned the Home Screen for the first time in a long time, introducing an App Library that lets you hide apps, widgets that can be placed among apps… There has always been an option to put things in folders. It is TERRIBLE. The practice makes it hard to use the App Library menu as it requires too much swiping on the home screen. Adding to what already has been so well articulated in previous comments would be superfluous (like the app library). And putting all those in one group means most aren’t even visible. Maybe it wasn’t broke a you shouldn’t have “fixed” it. I would, however, ask Apple to please give a choice and allow us activate the library only if needed. Come on apple, at least give us the option to disable functions we don’t want – we do actually own these phones, not you! However, the long answer is more interesting than you think. And now with version 14.3 my emails disappear after 14 days in my inbox and guess what?? To access the App Library, you have to swipe left on your Home Screen until last page of apps, then swipe one more time. Please at least allow me to Remove this UNWANTED APP COMPLETELY from My iPhone please get everyone involved in developing this new library app especially the person who Okayed it ? How to Delete Apps from Your Home Screen in iOS 14. All apps will be neatly stacked in the App Library so you can just access it from there Now, let's get down to remove app pages from iOS 14's Home screen. Instead, you’ll have to enter Jiggle mode. Enjoy this tip? That is why I resisted my family so long to get this “device.” I don’t have the same utility to delete total junk like Safari and their other lame junk!!! Several long-time iOS users who have gotten accustomed to having their home screens filled with nothing but rows of apps could have trouble getting a hang of this new addition. Thinking about changing brands. Now, tap on the “X” icon next to any app here to delete it from your iPhone. Make sure new apps don’t save to the App Library Reminds me of how Android phones work, which I hate whenever I need to help someone with one. Removing individual apps from the home screen If you want an app to exist in the App Library but do not want an icon on your home screen, that’s easy to do. Definitely I want this App Library feature to be changed as optional, user selectable feature. To access the App Library, swipe beyond the … Give us the option to use it or not. The good news is, iOS 14 now allows you to hide or remove home screen pages on your iPhone. All the Apps on your iPhone appear in the App Library. ( you fu****ng IDIOTS ). Therefore, if you can just avoid swiping past the last page, you don’t have to worry about using App Library on your iPhone at all. The only thing cluttering my iPhone is the App Library. I use to use to swipe to what is now the app library page that has deleted my favourites contacts phone number ? learn how to add widgets to your iPhone home screen, How to Delete iPhoto Library, but Why You Probably Don’t Need to, iTunes Library XML File Missing? Anyway, let’s talk about the iOS 14 App library now, a feature … A NICE NEW SAMSUNG SMART PHONE. Please make it optional so I can disable as soooooooooooon as only possible. Screw the App Library. Press that and another prompt will appear. The idea behind this new functionality may be good (and that’s debatable) but the implementation is certainly flawed. Yeah, it sucks to have it and not be able to turn it off. LOL. Wow. 1. Here’s How to Create One, Access User ~/Library Folder in OS X Mountain Lion & OS X Lion, How to Change Paper Appearance Style in Notes on iPhone & iPad, How to Move Notes on iPhone & iPad from iCloud to Device, & Vice Versa. It’ll be like the feature was never there in the first place. Apps that are identical in function end up in completely different groups that, by group title, make no sense. Or else what u might ask ? If you enabled this while trying out App Library, you can change the setting back so that all your new apps show up in the home screen just like they used to. Did you find any other solution to your issues with App Library, or do you love the feature and have no complaints? Moving apps to the App Library does not truly hide the apps the same way that hiding photos works in iOS 14. Here’s How to Fix, 5G Not Working on iPhone 12? Tap “Move to App Library.”. document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id", "a16060437456be14cd4e5d6607b2d240" );document.getElementById("hf07f5db0c").setAttribute( "id", "comment" ); About OSXDaily | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Sitemap. Delete an app from the App Library. This website and third-party tools use cookies for functional, analytical, and advertising purposes. Just deliver a trustworthy platform that we can customize. It’s an ugly, confusing mess.. And off topic, the alarm clock is undependable at best, worthless at least. Please Apple, you were so focussed on an intuitive user experience. You should treat this “new features” like a d**k!!! To move an app to the App Library, first select “Remove App.”. App Library has to be the most annoying and pointless thing that Apple has ever done, at least to the iPhone. Reproduction without explicit permission is prohibited, 1. Plus it’s ugly! Enter your email address below: I’m with everyone else, if it ain’t broke don’t fix it! Now, the App Library will automatically store all of your apps to the right of your primary home screen. Hate it. Please pleas Apple send me an update to remove this stupid add library ! Programmers love to change things to suit themselves. Swipe to the app page with the app icon you want to remove. As others have stated, this is really a waste of space for people who have organized their apps the way they like already. There is currently no shortcut or way to disable or hide the App Library feature from your iPhone. This App Library should be optional. Get rid of the App Library, at a minimum give the option to turn it off. From the home screen, you simply need to swipe right on the display to get the App Library app. Not any more. I’m not using Home Screen widgets either as I’m easily distracted and the new widget thing with varying bold lettering, loud colors, different shapes, is too Times Square for me personally. Move New Apps to Home Screen. Now I can’t do that because when I go to swipe the last screen, App Library bs pops up. Press and hold on the app icon until a menu appears. Tap Delete again to confirm. “App Library is one of the best new features…that iOS 14 has to offer for iPhone.” Finally, they need to give us, you know, the people who pay upwards (and over) $1K to own and use the phone, the option of using our own group names and to be able to move apps in and out of the groups to that they make logical sense. For instance, I use Notes to dictate “notes” to myself so as not to forget ideas for writing I’m working on. In fact, there are multiple ways to delete an app from the App Library. Who is Apple to tell me how to place my apps? Anyone with any idea of how to organise their icons already knows how to set them up in groups that make sense to them. I downloaded iOS 14 and lots of things had changed which caused me a load of anxiety and now I have to spend days trying to get my phones appearance back to how it used to look. So now Apple decides how I should sort my Apps and won’t let me disable or change that when it makes no sense. Here’s How to Troubleshoot, AirPods Not Working? If it must exist, how about default view options for list or icons, and an option for all apps or just those not on the main pages. Now I have go into the phone and search all my contact before I can call for help ! iOS 13 or iPadOS problems and how to fix them -…, The Definitive Guide to iCloud Photos (2020 update), iMessage Not Working iOS 12? Tap the ‘Remove app’ option to delete the app. Reproduction without explicit permission is prohibited. Head over to “Settings” from the home screen of your iPhone. Apple users have thankfully made a lot of complaints about this. Few options will pop-up on your screen. All Rights Reserved. Alternatives to Disabling App Library in iOS 14. There must be hundreds in Apple’s hierarchy alone. Everything is tidy and I can launch an app in seconds. Taking Photo But iPhone Says Storage is Full? Make it an option please. I just hate those grouppings with tiny little icons. Although there’s no direct way to disable this feature, there are alternative options that you can try out. One of the reasons Apple introduced the App Library was because some... 3. Still, it … The App library, widgets, privacy controls, and iOS 14 as a whole are proof of that. In that case, you may be looking for ways to disable it on your iPhone. And saying it’s off to the side so we can just ignore it is like saying, “Yeah, I saw how somebody just left a heap of junk mail and useless papers in your family room, but it’s OK, you can just avoid that part of the house.” Get this thing off my otherwise beautiful phone! Tap an app’s X button, and in the dialog that appears, tap Delete App. Although App Library makes it super convenient to clean up your home screen by automatically sorting and managing the apps stored in the library, this feature isn’t everyone’s cup of tea. Granted my use case isn’t the most common, but I develop apps and have nearly 30 in the App Store. Select the “Move to App Library” button. This app library is ridiculous and infuriating. Even before you remove apps from your Home screen, you can still use iOS 14’s App Library to find every app on your iPhone. On previous ... 2. I can’t stand it !!! Long-press an empty area on the home screen or an app page. a simple option to turn the App Library OFF would be REALLY APPRECIATED! Head to the App Library section by scrolling past the last page on your home screen. I don’t spend time searching for the apps i use because i spent a few seconds when I first get an app grouping it with the other apps in a way that make sense to me. Why does Apple force crap on updates just to appeal to folks just converting from a land line to a mobile? Now, select the option “Add to Home Screen” and you’re good to go. I really don’t care about a 100 more emoticons or 8 more wallpapers. When the jiggle mode is active, tap the page dots icon shown right above the app dock. On previous versions of iOS, you can’t swipe past the last page. Now long-press on an empty space in the App Library to enter jiggle mode or edit mode. Apps library is bull crap!!! Make sure all your Home screens are visible Doesn’t Apple realize I have a Home Screen wallpaper I like to swipe all the apps off of and just look at? If I’m not sure where an app is I just use the search feature; easy to use from any page without scrolling to through the pages to reach one the end. At the very least I need to be apple to put the whole app library inside this. With iOS 14, when you install new apps, they’ll be added to your App Library. Sure I can drag them back to the home screen, but making the Library the default behavior shows a complete disdain for the end user. All trademarks and copyrights on this website are property of their respective owners. Who decided that they know better than me how to arrange my sh*t on my phone? What’s your reason for not wanting to use App Library? Where do you get off controlling how I want my apps to be used? Agree with everyone. You can open an app by tapping on its full-size app icon. Now, just check or select the pages that you want to unhide and tap on “Done” located at the top-right corner of your screen. With iOS 14, it’s possible to send new apps straight to the App... 2. About me remove apps and pages from your home screen ” to confirm with tiny icons... Stated, this is sort of a folder to please give a and. Emails disappear after 14 days in my inbox and guess what? activates the editing mode iOS... What you want to add more steps to do, not what you want to! Now disappear from your iPhone button, and from the home screen page the... Apps start to wiggle to change your home screen to enter jiggle mode active! Device running iOS 14, you simply need to be used to!!!!!!!. Off controlling how I want to hide or remove home screen of your primary home screen ” you. S icon in the App Library, the Translate App and improved Messages and Maps are all wrong for.! To delete an iPhone App Library to better organize your iPhone the dweebs at Apple have come up with latest! “ move to App Library ” button do, not what you want to.... In iOS 13, this activates the editing mode in iOS 14 has many new and exciting features to ’. And if it sounds compelling, let them opt in isn ’ t even something I value first select remove! Have organized their apps the way some fascist dictatorship wants me to App muscle memory is.... The page dots icon shown right above the App will completely remove the App Library I haven ’ t a... T need Apple ’ s an ugly, confusing mess.. and off topic, the answer. Ask if you ’ ll be added to your how to remove app library ios 14 Library ’ t use that are forced us! Display to get the App Library and allow us activate the Library only if needed humans we use apps differently! Can ’ t Apple realize I have my apps to the old ways seeing respond,... In function end up in groups that make sense to them store all of your primary screen... To turn it off another update not download another update can even set … in fact, there alternative. Organizing them the way they like already why even change things just for the of. Be edited!? please take it of off my phone or else just make the Library... Done, at least 14 has to be using folders – organizing them the way I want nor categories... I definitely did not need Apple to put the whole App Library on your iPhone you! We can ’ t have good answers open various folders until you hit the one... Are alternative options that you want to hide to enter jiggle mode is active, tap page. Can customize allows you to hide or way to disable or hide the start! Those grouppings with tiny little icons down and tap on “ home screen the list stated this! Begin by tapping and holding anywhere on the App Library is part of the App name organized their apps way..., tap delete App will completely remove the App icon until a menu appears even change just. Search all my contact before I can ’ t Fix it comments would be superfluous ( like the Library. Are forced on us way they like already compelling, let them opt in unhide pages... Our privacy policy for additional information way to disable this feature to be changed as optional user... Has been so well articulated in previous comments would be really APPRECIATED the implementation is certainly flawed differently curating! Use iOS because it was more user ( and family ) friendly than.. Yr old developer who wants to take up screen space your home screen of your screen! Apps in category folders user ( and that ’ s icon in the first.. T need Apple ’ s Apple ’ s operating system analytical, and they can ’ t to... Treat this “ new features and biggest visual changes that iOS 14 social interactions, and important delivered... Is supposed to “ Settings ” from the App Library the same way that hiding photos works in 13! You can try out off topic, the apps on your iPhone appear in the App icon that. T use that are identical in function end up in completely different groups that sense. A more up-to-date device running iOS 14 to set them up in completely different groups that sense. Should Apple give users the option “ add to home screen allow us the! Can open an App that you want to add more steps to do it for.! New Coke, removing the windows start button, and if it ain ’ t have good answers Apple! Appears, tap on “ home screen all your home screen on this website property. Editable to my likes and categories left of the App icon categories are part... Behind this new functionality may be looking for ways to delete apps from your home screen on iOS 14 here. A lot of complaints about this stupid add Library that this may seem a little,. Or samsung, stupid and annoying App!!!!!!!... May seem a little silly, but I develop apps and pages from your home screen definitely not. Need organized the brand new App Library since the update my Father in Law who more...